Why is sealant not a chimney flashing?
Because a flashing works by overlap and gravity, while sealant works by adhesion and has a much shorter life. A bead of mastic along the junction sheds water for a season or two, then cracks away from the brick and channels water into the gap it has created.
The giveaway on an inspection is a thick, repeatedly renewed smear along the junction with no metal visible underneath. That usually means the detail was never built properly, and each renewal has made the next proper repair a little harder.
A correctly formed detail has metal stepped up each side, let into the brickwork and capped, so water is always being directed out onto the covering rather than being asked to stay out by a glue. It costs more once and then stops being a problem.
Is it the flashing or the brickwork?
Either, and on older stacks often both. A chimney stands fully exposed above the roof, so its mortar weathers faster than the rest of the house, and water entering open joints or a cracked crown runs down inside the masonry and emerges below. New flashing will not stop that.
The pattern helps: damp that follows wind-driven rain from one direction, or appears on a chimney breast well below roof level, points at the masonry. Water that arrives at the ceiling right beside the stack during ordinary rain points at the flashing.
With roughly four in ten city homes dating from before 1940 by an older Census-based analysis, there is a lot of old mortar standing above roof level in this region. Pointing the stack and repairing its crown is often the larger half of the job.
What about an unused chimney?
It still needs to be weathertight, and it is frequently the forgotten one. A disused flue collects rain, which soaks into the masonry and into the breast inside the house, and a crown or cap in poor condition makes it worse. Capping properly, with ventilation, is the usual answer.
Removing a stack below the roof line is another option, and that turns into a roofing job because the opening has to be closed up and made weathertight in the covering. It is a bigger scope than a flashing repair and may be a permit question.
Where a flue is still in use for an appliance, anything affecting it should be discussed with whoever services that appliance. The roof side of the work is the flashing, the crown and the cap; what happens inside the flue is a separate trade.
Does chimney work need a permit or review?
Flashing repair is normally maintenance. Rebuilding or removing a stack is structural work and a different conversation with Licenses and Inspections, or with the township, borough or New Jersey municipality outside the city. On a designated property, work visible from the street may also need Historical Commission review.
Chimneys are conspicuous by nature, which is why designation matters here more than for a hidden flat roof. The Commission's guidance favours work that is inconspicuous from the public right-of-way, and it confirms what applies to a particular address.
Scope is what decides the filing, so describe the work accurately when you ask: new flashing and pointing is not the same application as taking two feet off a stack. Our guide on roof permits in Philadelphia explains how it is filed.